nacams logo
  • nacams logo
  • Buy Policy
  • Renew
  • Liability Insurance
    • Yoga
    • Massage
      • Animal
      • Reflexology
      • Reiki
      • Equine
    • Fitness & Movement
      • Personal Training
      • Pilates
      • Dance
      • Barre
      • Kinesiology
      • Physical Therapy
      • Occupational Therapy
    • Cosmetology
      • Hair
      • Nail
    • Esthetician
      • Body Contouring
      • Microblading
      • Microneedling
  • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Professional Rates
    • Student Rates
    • Disciplines Covered
    • Policy Exclusions
    • Insurance Guide
      • New To Insurance?
    • Blog
    • FAQs
    • Resources
  • Members
    • Member Portal
    • Member Benefits
    • AI Request Form
  • 1 (800) 964-0158

NACAMS

vs

Philadelphia Insurance Co (PHLY)

Ready to make the switch? You're not alone.

We know buying liability insurance can come with a lot of questions. For most professionals, it's an item on a checklist that feels more like a chore than an exciting choice. 

NACAMS exists to help break that stigma. Here are a few reasons we think our membership is a great choice over PHYL.

Buy Policy

Table of Contents

  • About The Company
  • Coverage Limits
  • Policy Types
  • Customer Service
  • Extras / Benefits
  • Price

Or jump to our Quick Comparison Guide

About The Company

NACAMS

The National Association of Complementary and Alternative Medicines (NACAMS) founded in 2005 serves health, wellness, and beauty professionals by offering comprehensive liability insurance and practice support. NACAMS does not certify or register professionals or schools. Instead, we offer the industry preferred and affordable insurance options.

In 2019 NACAMS was acquired by Arthur J Gallagher, the 3rd largest brokerage in the world allowing us to grow and enhance our services.

PHYL

Philadelphia Insurance Companies (PHLY) is a subsidiary of their parent company, Tokio Marine North America, Inc., the U.S. holding for the Japanese based Tokio Marine Group.

The original company was founded in 1962 by James J. Maguire, Sr. and was originally known as the Maguire Insurance Agency. In its beginnings, the Maguire Insurance Agency specialized in automobile insurance products. It expanded from one to 15 offices shortly thereafter. After changing its name to PHLY in 1987, the company began offering liability insurance to social service agencies, as well as health and fitness organizations. In 2008, Founder Maguire began the process of merging PHLY with the Tokio Marine Group.

Coverage Limits

NACAMS

Professional and general liability insurance are included in the NACAMS membership. Sometimes companies will separate these types of liability insurance requiring the customer to choose one or the other or both for an additional cost. 

  • Professional & General Liability Insurance: $2 million per occurrence; $3 million individual annual aggregate
  • Personal Injury & Advertising Coverage: $2 million individual aggregate
  • Identity Protection Coverage: $25,000

Policy limits were chosen based on what industry professionals need. 


PHYL

PHLY offers personal, commercial property/ casualty, and professional lines of insurance to various niche markets, including the health, fitness and wellness industry. 

Policy Type

NACAMS

We are occurrence form coverage meaning you are covered after your policy expires as long as the incident occurred while your policy was active. 

PHYL

PHYL is also occurrence form coverage. This type of policy is a higher priced option naturally based on the comprehensive aspect.  

Customer Service & Reviews

NACAMS

We strongly feel a customer's experience is the most important aspect of purchasing insurance. That is why we prioritize a seamless process with as little roadblocks as possible to get insured. Our customer support team is U.S. based and happy to assist you with any questions to make sure you get the peace of mind you need to feel confident. 

We are rated Excellent on independent review site, Trustpilot and 5 stars on Google Reviews.

PHYL

Philadelphia Insurance Companies is rated Poor (2.4) on independent review site, Trustpilot and 3 our of 5 starts on Google Review.

Extras / Benefits

NACAMS

When you choose NACAMS, you are also choosing to be apart of a wider network which includes extra benefits for no additional cost. Once you have purchased you gain access to our exclusive benefits which include a free website, access to our Health Insurance Marketplace, discounts on larger expenses like hotels, rental cars, and even a free month of online mental health counseling. 

PHYL

They do not offer additional benefits beyond their liability insurance. 

Price

NACAMS

The reason why NACAMS is the best choice for liability insurance is our all-inclusive membership model with one low annual price that encompasses all limits & benefits. Choose the one that best fits your need and get insured in the same day.


  • One Year Student: $60
  • One Year Pro: $179
  • Two Year Pro: $329

PHYL

PHYL has a few different policy options to choose from with differing limits with a range of prices. As you walk through the application you must choose each option to create your perfect policy. 

Comparing NACAMS coverage & benefits the average price for a PHYL policy is $185/Year. 

Quick Comparison Guide

Here are just a few things our simple insurance has that others don't offer:

Feature

NACAMS

PHYL

500 Modalities Included

Instant Coverage

Free Website

Professional & General Liability

Identity Protection

Occurrence Form Policy

Affordable Student Rate

Educational Resources

Membership Benefits

One Flat Rate

Ready To Take Your Next Step? We're Here For You.

FULL time

1 Year

$179

BUY POLICY

Full time

2 Year (saves you $29!)

$329

BUY POLICY

Student

1 Year

$60

BUY POLICY

Student Policy Notice: to be eligible for the student policy, you must be currently enrolled in your first training course.

  • About Us
  • What We Cover
  • Contact Us
  • Insurance Liability Guide
NACAMS

Speak with an Agent Now: 1 (800) 964-0158
8430 Enterprise Circle Suite 200, Lakewood Ranch, FL 34202

The Liability master policy is issued to the Healthcare Professionals Purchasing Group, LLC. The Identity Protection Plan is powered by Identity Fraud, Inc., Walnut Creek, CA, whose members include members of Healthcare Professionals Purchasing Group, LLC. Gallagher Affinity Insurance Services, Inc. is the insurance partner for Healthcare Professionals Purchasing Group, LLC. Gallagher Affinity Insurance Services, Inc., a 50-state licensed broker, is the broker for all coverage under Healthcare Professionals Purchasing Group, LLC. Gallagher Affinity Insurance Services, Inc. also serves as excess and surplus lines broker for Healthcare Professionals Purchasing Group, LLC. Professional Liability and Commercial General Liability coverage under Healthcare Professionals Purchasing Group, LLC is underwritten in the surplus lines market by an A rated (Excellent) insurance company, per A.M. Best Company. Persons insured by surplus lines companies are not eligible for recourse through any state guarantee fund for the obligations of an insolvent insurer. Healthcare Professionals Purchasing Group, LLC is for health, wellness and beauty professionals and students created for the purpose of providing valuable and important benefits and services to its members. Healthcare Professionals Purchasing Group, LLC is not an insurer. 8430 Enterprise Circle Suite 200, Lakewood Ranch, FL 34202.

Copyright © 2025 NACAMS, A Gallagher Company. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Agreement To Do Business | Sitemap

Trustpilot
National Association Complementary & Alternative Medicines BBB Business Review